Guess who fixed the library girl thread to work?... ME!!!
OK, here's what the problem was:
the sql query was getting the user info while it gets the post... and wherever moose or chuck had posted, it couldn't find a user account for them (cause they deleted their old accounts)... so what i did is changed their user id to anonymous, and the username to "Moose or Chuck" for all those posts...
so everything should be working dandy now.